資源描述:
《Robinson WI - Global and World Cities - A View from Off the Map》由會(huì)員上傳分享,免費(fèi)在線閱讀,更多相關(guān)內(nèi)容在教育資源-天天文庫(kù)。
1、InternationalJournalofUrbanandRegionalResearchVolume26.3September2002531±54GlobalandWorldCities:AViewfromofftheMap*JENNIFERROBINSONTherearealargenumberofcitiesaroundtheworldwhichdonotregisteronintellectualmapsthatcharttheriseandfallofglobalandworldcities.Theydon'tfall
2、intoeitherofthesecategories,andtheyprobablyneverwillDbutmanymanagersofthesecitieswouldlikethemto.Someofthesecitiesfindthemselvesinterpretedinsteadthroughthelensofdevelopmentalism,anapproachwhichbroadlyunderstandstheseplacestobelackinginthequalitiesofcity-ness,andwhich
3、isconcernedtoimprovecapacitiesofgovernance,serviceprovisionandproductivity.Suchanapproachsupportssomeofthemorealarmistresponsestomega-cities,whicharemorecommonlyidentifiedinpoorercountries.Butformanysmallercities,eventhecategorymega-cityisirrelevant.Myconcernsinthisar
4、ticleextendbeyondthepoorfitofthesepopularcategories,though.IwouldliketosuggestthatthesewidelycirculatingapproachestocontemporaryurbanizationDglobalandworldcities,togetherwiththepersistentuseofthecategory`third-worldcity'Dimposesubstantiallimitationsonimaginingorplanni
5、ngthefuturesofcitiesaroundtheworld.Partoftheadverseworldlyimpactoftheseurbantheoriesis,Iargue,aconsequenceofthegeographicaldivisionofurbanstudiesbetweenurbantheory,broadlyfocusedontheWest,anddevelopmentstudies,focusedonplacesthatwereoncecalled`third-worldcities'.Thisd
6、ivisionmightsimplybeaninnocentacknowledgementofdifference(Szelenyi,1996).However,apartfromthevalue-ladenhistoricalmeaningofthesecategoricalascriptions,thepersistentalignmentofa`theory'/`development'dualismwith1the`West'/`thirdworld'divisioninurbanstudies,suggestsother
7、wise.Oneoftheconsequencesoftheseoverlappingdualisms,isthatunderstandingsofcity-nesshavecometorestonthe(usuallyunstated)experiencesofarelativelysmallgroupof(mostlywestern)cities,andcitiesoutsideoftheWestareassessedintermsofthispre-given*Ishouldliketothankpeoplewhoatten
8、dedvariousseminarswhereearlyversionsofthisarticlewerepresentedDatBirmingham,LoughboroughandKingsCollegeLondonGeographyDepart