資源描述:
《the r book tree models》由會(huì)員上傳分享,免費(fèi)在線閱讀,更多相關(guān)內(nèi)容在工程資料-天天文庫(kù)。
1、21Meta-AnalysisThereisacompellingcasetobemadethatanalystsshouldlookatthewholebodyofevidence,ratherthantryingtounderstandindividualstudiesinisolation.Thesystematicreviewofabodyofevidenceisknownasmeta-analysis.Theideaistodrawtogetheralloftheappropriatestudiesthathaveaddressedthesame
2、question,andcalculateanoveralleffectandanoverallmeasureofuncertainlyforthateffect.Ofcourse,thereareplentyofissueswiththis,amongthemthefollowing:Whatdowemeanby‘thesamequestion’?Whatisanappropriatestudy?Whatmakesastudyinappropriate?Howdifferentcanastudybe,andstillbeworthincludin
3、ginthemeta-analysis?Whatarethepublicationbiasesinthevariousstudies?Aretheeffects?xedorrandom?Thecentralideaistoremoveasmuchaspossibleofthesubjectivitythatwassuchafeatureofold-fashionednarrativereviews.Inanidealworld,weshouldbeabletoextractfromeverypublishedstudytheexactquestiona
4、ddressed,theeffectsize,thevarianceofthateffect,thereplication,andenoughdetailonthemethodsusedtobecon?dentthatthestudywascomparablewiththeothersthatwehavealreadyincluded.Thenwesimplycalculateaweightedaverageeffectsizeandanappropriateweightedaveragemeasureoftheunreliabilityofthatove
5、ralleffect.Andthatwouldbeit.Iftheeffectisconsistentacrossexperiments,thisgivesconsiderablecon?denceinitsgenerality,andthesizeoftheeffectisausefulmeasureofitsimportance.Ontheotherhand,iftheeffectisfoundtobeinconsistentacrossexperiments,thenitsgeneralityiscalledintoquestion,andfurth
6、erstudiesarerequiredtounderstandwhytheeffectwassovariable.Meta-analysisrequires:clearrulesfortheselectionofstudies;clearrulesfortheomissionofstudies;simpleprotocolsforassigningastatisticalweighttoeachstudy;TheRBook,SecondEdition.MichaelJ.Crawley.?2013JohnWiley&Sons,Ltd.Publishe
7、d2013byJohnWiley&Sons,Ltd.META-ANALYSIS741agreedmethodsforcalculatinganappropriatemeasureofuncertainlyfortheeffect;suf?cientdetailintheMethodssectionthatanotheranalystwouldgetexactlythesameresult,andcometoexactlythesameconclusion,iftheyweretorepeattheanalysisusingthesamegroupofs
8、tudies.Ameta-analysisofexistingst